"id","site","timestamp","year","place","dataset","answers","reviewed","reviewResult","reviewComments","details","isCurrent","isOpen","submitter","reviewer","score","relativeScore"
"b17716ce-3be2-4930-8712-8a147139d32f","br-cities","2018-03-03T16:48:21","2017","cb","weather","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search city name and forecast data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Simepar / INPE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Temperature average"",""Wind speed"",""Wind direction"",""Precipitation Amount"",""Precipitation Probability"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.simepar.br/site/internas/conteudo/meteorologia/tempo.shtml?id=4106902"",""descValue"":""Simepar Curitiba""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.simepar.br/"",""descValue"":""Simepar All Cities in Paraná""},{""urlValue"":""http://bancodedados.cptec.inpe.br/"",""descValue"":""INPE (Not for commercial purposes)""},{""urlValue"":""http://bancodedados.cptec.inpe.br/downloadBDM/"",""descValue"":""INPE download data (Requires Registration)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Stephan Garcia","100","100"
"8f0c715b-7655-46ed-ae2d-be8feda9cbe6","br-cities","2018-03-03T17:30:46","2017","cb","crime","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""RDF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search for \""Crime Statistics in Curitiba\"" in Portuguese"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SESP Secretaria de Segurança Pública do Paraná"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Number of robbery"",""Number of murder"",""Number of rapes"",""Firearm seizures"",""Data available per neighborhood or equivalent""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.seguranca.pr.gov.br/modules/conteudo/conteudo.php?conteudo=38"",""descValue"":""Crims Statistics SESP""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.ondefuiroubado.com.br/curitiba/PR"",""descValue"":""Onde fui Roubado - Third party""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"Data is updated Yearly. The third party is real time by the citizens.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephan Garcia","85","85"
"8f7067cd-0440-45cc-9f52-6e4e7133ee60","br-cities","2018-03-03T17:12:19","2017","cb","boundaries","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""GeoJSON"",""HTML"",""RDF"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First link on google, \""equipamentos urbanos de curitiba\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""    http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IPPUC"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.ippuc.org.br/"",""descValue"":""IPPUC""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.ippuc.org.br/default.php?visualizar=equipamentospastasseuc.php"",""descValue"":""Equipamentos urbanos""},{""urlValue"":""http://dadosabertos.c3sl.ufpr.br/curitibaurbs/"",""descValue"":""Data and coordinate of ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Stephan Garcia","100","100"
"893081c0-4230-4a09-b21e-28219ed9d8fa","br-cities","2018-03-03T17:34:37","2017","cb","law","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Google"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Câmara Municipal de Curitiba"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.cmc.pr.gov.br/transparencia/portarias-e-atos/index.php"",""descValue"":""Portarias, Atos e Diário Oficial""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The data is available only in PDF format. ","Yes","No","Stephan Garcia","Stephan Garcia","70","70"
"e8691649-985c-4668-8060-348dba64e096","br-cities","2017-03-04T19:19:39","2017","cb","water","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Access direct link or second link to search"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Sanepar"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Fluoride levels"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.sanepar.com.br/sanepar/usav/resultados.nsf/Analises?OpenAgent&Cod=001"",""descValue"":""Water quality of Curitiba""},{""urlValue"":""http://site.sanepar.com.br/conteudo/analise-da-qualidade-da-agua"",""descValue"":""Water quality of cities of Parana""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Daniel Ikenaga","Stephan Garcia","60","60"
"760573d9-e8f7-44b0-8d82-e426fae295f1","br-cities","2017-03-05T16:26:34","2017","cb","land","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""PDF""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First link on google."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria Municipal dePlanejamento, Finanças e Orçamento"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value"",""Tenure Type""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www2.curitiba.pr.gov.br/gtm/iptu/carnet/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Private data of IPTU""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Daniel Ikenaga","Stephan Garcia","35","35"
"9b7730fe-671c-437a-a57d-33bd2717b6f6","br-cities","2017-03-04T20:04:56","2017","cb","emissions","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Boletim anual atualizado apenas até 2013""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""PDF""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Searched for \""qualidade do ar em Curitiba\"" on Google "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.iap.pr.gov.br/modules/conteudo/conteudo.php?conteudo=92"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IAP - Instituto Ambiental do Paraná"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.iap.pr.gov.br/modules/conteudo/conteudo.php?conteudo=92"",""descValue"":""Gestão de Qualidade do Ar""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","Stephan Garcia","60","60"
"bdc8573a-7c83-464f-9730-4a05c5e89a3b","br-cities","2017-03-05T15:14:38","2017","cb","procurement","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""PDF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""First result in google."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""E-Compras"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.e-compras.curitiba.pr.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""Procurement""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Daniel Ikenaga","Stephan Garcia","80","80"
"c76d71dd-8c5c-4e33-a734-da8bdfdbcf9f","br-cities","2017-03-04T21:10:34","2017","cb","postcodes","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""There is no government entity responsable for that information. All the zipcode related dats are owned by the public owned mail company (Correios S/A)."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Russeonardo L","Stephan Garcia","0","0"
"e4621249-b0fa-4157-8f89-0e72e6302ee1","br-cities","2017-03-04T20:21:06","2017","cb","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""PDF""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Search by type of data"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Câmara Municipal de Curitiba"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of the city council"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.cmc.pr.gov.br/wspl/sistema/ProposicaoConsultaForm.do"",""descValue"":""Search draft legislation""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.cmc.pr.gov.br/wspl/sistema/NotasTaquigraficasListarForm.do#"",""descValue"":""Transcript of debates""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Daniel Ikenaga","Stephan Garcia","80","80"
"56e5d77f-d208-450e-8f5c-a92e92ac8db7","br-cities","2017-03-04T20:06:46","2017","cb","education","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Apenas dados até 2015\nNão há dados disponíveis para 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Procurado no Google palavras chave \""Censo\"" \""Curitiba\"" \""Educação\"" \""Escolar\"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria de Estado da Educação PR"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Data available for Kindergarten, Elementary and High School""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Os dados não estão atualizados neste site da Secretaria de Educação""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.educacao.pr.gov.br/modules/conteudo/coudo=60nteudo.php?conte"",""descValue"":""Censo Escolar Curitiba 2016""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""não encontramos dados do censo referente ao ano de 2016""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","leandro moraes","Stephan Garcia","85","85"
"6e30eb38-10b3-4720-bc2a-2fc67183e5fb","br-cities","2017-03-04T17:12:08","2017","cb","transport","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""PDF"",""none""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Download pdf file and search it."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""URBS"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Stop/stations for every transportation mode""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://urbs.curitiba.pr.gov.br/transporte/taxis"",""descValue"":""Taxis cabstand""},{""urlValue"":""http://urbs.curitiba.pr.gov.br/pdf/transporte/taxi/Centrais_de_Radiotaxi_em_Curitiba.pdf"",""descValue"":""Taxis central contact""},{""urlValue"":""http://urbs.curitiba.pr.gov.br/institucional/legislacao"",""descValue"":""Taxis legislation""},{""urlValue"":""http://urbs.curitiba.pr.gov.br/pdf/transporte/taxi/Informativo_Taxi.jpg"",""descValue"":""Taxis tax services""},{""urlValue"":""http://urbs.curitiba.pr.gov.br/mobile/taxiLegal"",""descValue"":""Official taxi  driver""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Daniel Ikenaga","Stephan Garcia","60","60"
"caf25a85-5211-40f7-b493-6b918128b9e6","br-cities","2017-05-26T20:10:40","2017","sp","land","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The dataset is downloadable at once through the open data portal, but not through geosampa.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is also available in .ODS format.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data from 2016 was updated in October 2016, as written in the footer.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data was not found in the first place. Only after comments from São Paulo city hall the data was found in geosampa portal. The .csv database could only be provided by searching for \""IPTU\"", which is the brazilian municipal property tax.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""The links were provided by the São Paulo City Hall and then analyzed by FGV/DAPP."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/base-de-dados-do-imposto-predial-e-territorial-urbano-iptu"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""On the left part of the page you can see that a Creative Commons Attribution License is provided.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is easy to use in general, but geolocation is provided separately through the geosampa portal.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Prefeitura Municipal de São Paulo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The GeoSampa portal is hosted within the website of the Municipal Department of Urban Development of the Municipality of São Paulo. The Secretariat is the city's governing body responsible for urban planning.  ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Parcel boundaries"",""Parcel ID"",""Property value"",""Tenure Type""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The ID provided is actually an ID for the taxpayer associated to that property. But since each property as its own taxpayer ID, this was considered as Parcel ID. Parcel boundaries are provided in geosampa portal, also with all location data (address and zipcodes). Property value can be obtained by multiplying the value per squared meter and the property area. The tenure type can be obtained through \""type of use\"" and \""type of construction pattern\"", the first one being more specific then the second one. For example: you can have \""comercial\"" as construction pattern and \""store\"" as type of use.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/base-de-dados-do-imposto-predial-e-territorial-urbano-iptu"",""descValue"":""The city hall provides all the data from geosampa through its Open Data portal""},{""urlValue"":""http://geosampa.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/PaginasPublicas/_SBC.aspx"",""descValue"":""Geolocation tool that the city hall makes available online. Searches for \""IPTU\"" can retrieve land ownership data per parcel of land.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The two sources contain the same data, but the first one permits bulk download in csv and the second one permits geolocation, though not available in bulk.""}]","Yes","Yes","This is a new submission after comments from the São Paulo City Hall, pointing to a website that actually contained the required information for 2016. Thanks to Paulo Uebel, Bruno Shibata and Thomaz Anderson da Silva for the contributions.","This is a new submission after comments from the São Paulo City Hall, pointing to a website that actually contained the required information. Thanks to Paulo Uebel, Bruno Shibata and Thomaz Anderson da Silva for the contributions.","Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"c35db2da-c7f0-44d5-86ac-f1abb6f72b8c","br-cities","2017-04-28T13:55:52","2017","rj","water","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not every information is available for download. Monthly reports containing all the information are available for download in pdf.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is available only in .pdf format.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Reports are monthly, not weekly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It was not very easy, first because I’m not a specialist in the area but also because it was hard to find the reports inside the website. It took some time for me to make sure that INEA was the best source of data. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I googled “water quality data rio de janeiro”, 2) I found some reports and references for INEA and the water and sanitation company in Rio de Janeiro (CEDAE), 3) I looked for water quality data in these two websites, found some information in both, 4) I consulted with a specialist in the area to decide which of them I would use as main reference. CEDAE provided more reports, but less useful data for this dimension."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.inea.rj.gov.br/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""At the webpage footer there is a mention to a Creative Commons Attribution License 2.0.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is difficult to use the data not only because it is only in pdf format but also because you need to understand the specifics of this kind of data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEA - Instituto Estadual do Ambiente"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""INEA, the state institute for the environment, even though it is a state government department, provides information for cities, including Rio de Janeiro. It is associated to the state secretariat of Environment.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Nitrates"",""Total Dissolved Solids"",""Data per water source"",""Available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The report doesn’t provide data on arsenic and fluoride levels. All the other are available in pdf per monitoring station in the Guanabara hydrographic region, that includes the city of Rio de Janeiro.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.inea.rj.gov.br/Portal/MegaDropDown/Monitoramento/Qualidadedaagua/aguasInteriores/Qualificaodeguas/index.htm&lang="",""descValue"":""INEA webpage where you can find monthly reports on water quality per hydrographic regions.""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.inea.rj.gov.br/cs/groups/public/documents/document/zwew/mdi2/~edisp/inea0026989.pdf"",""descValue"":""Example of the last report from october 2016.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn’t find a open data reference. The only source is these pdf reports.""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","45","45"
"051c97ec-ac50-408d-8d82-00cd7d694a0b","br-cities","2017-04-28T12:50:13","2017","rj","procurement","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can only get the data from each tender individually.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""when there is downloadable information it’s in pdf.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""yes. I can get  data from november 2016.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""the license to use the data isn’t clear but it’s public domain information because of brazilian law ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the transparency web page is easy to find, and is well organized.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew that information was in Rio’s city transparency website so I accessed it."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.acessoainformacao.gov.br/assuntos/conheca-seu-direito/a-lei-de-acesso-a-informacao"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""i can’t download the information, plus, to get to 2016 i have to select the last page. Because when i search, the first results are the oldest ones.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""The City Hall - Prefeitura do Rio de Janeiro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The city hall transparency webpage makes it available budget info on Rio’s city government budget""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can access all the information on e-compras but i can only download the information individually, one company at a time.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://prefeitura.rio/web/transparenciacarioca"",""descValue"":""there is a goverment expending session.""},{""urlValue"":""http://ecomprasrio.rio.rj.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""exclusive procurement website.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the first link directed me to the second link, where i got all the information i needed it.""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","60","60"
"bf6ec8dd-df27-4a24-883a-58c2d987bc7a","br-cities","2017-04-28T12:46:39","2017","rj","law","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only PDF is available.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is no license declaration in the website. Regarding the definition of copyright content stated by the Law 9.610/1998 in Article 7, XIII, a dataset will be copyrightable only if its organization involves an intellectual creation. In this case, data is primary or factual, so we can assume that it is open or public.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You type \""Rio de Janeiro\"" and \""Legislação\"", portuguese for \""Legislation\"" and then click at the first link."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is not a way to download information in a structured format, but there is a basic search engine where you can build queries to get the legislation you are interested in. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Municipal Administrative Secretary - Secretaria Municipal de Administração do do Rio de Janeiro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://smaonline.rio.rj.gov.br/conlegis/ConLegislacao.asp"",""descValue"":""Rio de Janeiro Municipal Administrative Secretary""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.camara.rj.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""Rio de Janeiro City Council ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The former presents all current legislation from  Rio de Janeiro. The second presents all the propositions that have been processed in  city council since 1977 (including draft legislation and non approved propositions). We will consider the first dataset to answer the following questions. ""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"6958ac06-9a13-4955-9bd7-ef07b198a7ca","br-cities","2017-04-28T12:21:51","2017","rj","budget","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Only PDF is available, not machine-readable though.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is no license declaration in the website. Regarding the definition of copyright content stated by the Law 9.610/1998 in Article 7, XIII, a dataset will be copyrightable only if its organization involves an intellectual creation. In this case, data is primary or factual, so we can assume that it is open or public.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I already used this dataset for research purpose.\n""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Type “Orçamento municipal Rio de Janeiro”, portuguese for “Rio de Janeiro Municipal Budget” and click on the first link."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is provided in a pdf format, so it is not readable by machines. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Finance Secretary of Rio de Janeiro (Secretaria de Fazenda do Rio de Janeiro)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www2.rio.rj.gov.br/smf/orcamento/loa.asp"",""descValue"":""Rio de Janeiro City Hall""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.camara.rj.gov.br/orcamento_municipal_loa.php?m1=legislacao&m2=orc_municipal&m3=loa"",""descValue"":""Rio de Janeiro City Council""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I will be considering the former in this evaluation. \n""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"4fd6f287-c29c-4cd1-8255-b5dbe247c0ce","br-cities","2017-04-27T14:15:52","2017","rj","education","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":"" I’ve got all brazilians school information when i download the school census. On the geodata i can get each school  type (municipal,  state or federal) separately. But overall, yes.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""the geolocation data is available on all 4 formats,  all the other data only on CSV.\n""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""although its 2017 and the last data available is from 2015, i know  based on previous knowledge they launch the data referring to the last year (in this case, 2016) every march, so, i’ll tick yes here.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data, since I’ve been working with them for a long time, so it was really easy to me. But if you google “educação dados inep” you’ll get to the page easily. and when you google schools location rio de janeiro you get the same.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""To get enrolment data, public school data and type of school (kindergarten, elementary and high school) i googled the inep data page, so i could download the school census for each year and filter the options to get only Rio’s city data. To get the geodata i looked for school info on rio’s open data center on geolocation: http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_Ato2015-2018/2016/Decreto/D8777.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" I didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" or a real license on INEP data, but the dataset is made available by an autarchy linked to the education ministry of the federal government, so it is considered licensed by the federal Decree 8.777/2016, Chapter II. On Rio city hall geo data the license is at the footer of the page:  http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" all data was easy to find and easy to get.\n""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEP - Instituto Nacional de Estudos e Pesquisas Educacionais Anísio Teixeira and Rio’s city hall"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The national research institute on education Anísio Teixeira is a federal autarchy linked to the Ministry of Education (MEC). Its objective is to promote studies, surveys and periodic evaluations on the Brazilian educational system""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Enrollment"",""Data available per public school"",""Data available for Kindergarten, Elementary and High School""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""can get the geolocation data on all public schools from rio, but the information is based on school admnistration: municipal, state or federal.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://portal.inep.gov.br/web/guest/dados"",""descValue"":""Inep has a download page with all kinds of data""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/"",""descValue"":""Rio’s city hall has a geolocation data website. If i search for schools i can get the geodata on it.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","This submission was reviewed in order to be in accordance with other assessments of the INEP database.",,"Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"db7ec4f2-7892-4e26-b756-5be2393afc3e","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:11:00","2017","rj","companies","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can only get the data from company to company once I've got the unique identifier number (CNPJ). and its not downloadable. The second link offers a downloadable list of IDs, but again, not comprehensive.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable in the first link, you can only access one-by-one information in a web platform, that’s why .HTML is selected. The second one permits download in .txt file, but it returns only IDs from service companies using the NFS-e system.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is free of charge, but i can only access it one by one in the first link. I have a list in the second link, but as I said before, it is not comprehensive. There is a private platform called SERASA, that sells a company’s list but this is a paid service. So it exists, it’s just not public available.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data on company register is updated every time there is a change in the company status. The document generated states its date of emission as the current date, to ensure validity.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not only it was not easy to find the two platforms but also, you need to have prior information on the company ID to get information in the first one. There is no official list beyond the one offered at the second link (which is not comprehensive enough), so I have to look up on the internet for the company's name  individually.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled “companies register Rio de Janeiro”. After some research into those links, I found the SMF/RJ platform and the list from the NFS-e companies. I had to get an example of company ID in order to generate the document in the first link to see what information I would get."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://prefeitura.rio/politica-de-privacidade"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no clear license in the link I provided. The only thing I found is that all content published in the Rio de Janeiro City Hall page is under a Creative Commons Attribution License 3.0, as stated in the link I put here. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is very hard to do anything with this information. I have to consult one by one, no download is available and the only option I have to get a full dataset doesn’t contain information for all companies in the city.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Rio de Janeiro Municipal Secretariat of Finance (Secretaria Municipal de Fazenda do Rio de Janeiro - SMF/RJ)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The city government secretariat of finance provides the same information that the Receita Federal (SRF),  the national equivalent for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), disposes about companies, but only those registered locally.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Register available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I need to have the prior information on the ID to get the rest of the information, so I understand that this information is not provided. No information is provided in a list, in the case of the first link, which is comprehensive.\nEven though the other link contains all the information required, it is not available for entire city, since it is a subset of companies.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://dief.rio.rj.gov.br/smf/certecweb/pesquisa.asp"",""descValue"":""This is the website from the SMF/RJ to get individual information for registered companies in the city of Rio de Janeiro. You need to fill in an ID to find the rest of information of each company.""},{""urlValue"":""http://notacarioca.rio.gov.br/gmaps/listaprestadores.aspx"",""descValue"":""For a subset of service sector companies that use the invoice electronic system (NFS-e) created by the Rio de Janeiro City Hall, there is a complete list of companies with the name of the company, its ID and the address.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""To look up the individual information at the  webpage of the Secretariat of Finance, I need the CNPJ (unique identifier) number of the company. This website doesn’t provide a list, just individual consultations. The other link generates a list, but not all companies are available, only service sector companies using the NFS-e system.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.","In Brazil, state institutions called “Junta Comercial” (roughly translated as board of trading) should have the information on all companies with a state inscription. For Rio de Janeiro, the information is actually there, since there is a possibility to subscribe into the website and ask for individual certificates of each company registered in the state. This process requires subscription and payment, though. Here’s the website of the Rio de Janeiro Board of Trading: https://www.jucerja.rj.gov.br/JucerjaPortalWeb/default.aspx","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","60","60"
"56548728-8dc7-40cd-b4d4-6279c7aa1c0c","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:17:09","2017","rj","transport","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each information is provided separately, not only between transportation modes but also the type of information (itineraries separated from schedules separated from stations, etc).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GeoJSON files can be downloaded through the “API” link. Shapefile extensions are also available in .CPG and .PRJ. Spreadsheet comes directly in .CSV.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In general, data had the last update 2 months ago. Some of them had the last update in 2014. An evident missing update was for Subway stations and itineraries, that still didn’t provide data on the new line (Line 4) built in 2016.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data was scattered in many different maps and datasets through various websites, even though the majority of them was at “Portal Georio”, from IPP. It took me some time to realize that I had to click on the search button without a query in order to get the full list of datasets and then search for the transportation datasets. A specialist in the area helped me finding it and checking if the datasets contained what I was looking for.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I looked first at the “data storage” portal from IPP (http://www.armazemdedados.rio.rj.gov.br/), but I could only find digital maps that were not downloadable. 2) I consulted with a specialist for help and I finally came to “portal geo-rio” (http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/), which is a open geodata portal maintained by IPP. 3) I had to click on the search button without a query in order to get the full list of datasets and then search for the datasets I was looking for. 4) I checked with the specialist if it had the information needed."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All the data provided in the Geo-rio Portal above is under Creative Commons License called “Open Data Commons Open Database License (ODbL - http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/), as shown at the page footer. Information from DataRio portal is also under the same license. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are many formats in which data are available, but you should have some knowledge on geographic datasets in order to work with this (including knowledge in geographic softwares). I would also add the fact that data is scattered between many different sources, which makes it harder to work on data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IPP - Instituto Pereira Passos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Pereira Passos Institute (IPP) is the research department for Rio de Janeiro's City Government, responsible for collecting data, strategic planning and public policies integration, mapping, cartographic production and geotechnology application.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Stop/stations for every transportation mode"",""Itineraries for every line of every public transportation mode"",""Bike Lanes mapping for the entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data on stops/stations and itineraries for every transportation mode and the bike lanes for the entire city were available in the links provided. Schedules were only explicitly available for Ferry Boats. Buses had GPS real-time location data, which might be understood as a substitute for schedules. But all the other transportation modes had no data on schedules. Moreover, I couldn’t find explicit data on connections.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/7c472882a3804874918a2d46b447b23b_0"",""descValue"":""Bike Lanes Map""},{""urlValue"":""http://data.rio/dataset/pontos-dos-percursos-de-barcas/resource/ce880598-39fc-47ca-b0a0-94d7982867c5"",""descValue"":""Ferry Boat itineraries""},{""urlValue"":""http://data.rio/dataset/pontos-de-parada-de-barcas/resource/450357bf-8b56-40a3-9b03-098edfb29ba8"",""descValue"":""Ferry Boat Stations""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.grupoccr.com.br/barcas/linhas-horarios-tarifas"",""descValue"":""Ferry Boat Schedule""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/1c19278fa6f647b7aaabcdbbef6b8233_9"",""descValue"":""VLT (Veículo Leve sobre Trilhos - Tramway) itineraries""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/29cc383d2d344e8387dda153ec0d545d_10"",""descValue"":""VLT (Veículo Leve sobre Trilhos - Tramway) stations""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/8c9f264be1e946b1b49cf4c198bd5e46_16"",""descValue"":""Train stations""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/d159fcb3925d44bd90c3771a9077971a_15"",""descValue"":""Train itineraries""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/7a0b22723c5a458faaae79f046163504_19"",""descValue"":""Subway stations""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/df17c658dc9c4c3b82b964822f60b98f_18"",""descValue"":""Subway itineraries""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/f753941f44a749d4987f1111aa6486b3_22"",""descValue"":""BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) stations""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/d3c2b2a4bdba4aba8936bfdcc925c87d_23"",""descValue"":""BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) itineraries""},{""urlValue"":""http://data.rio/dataset/onibus-gtfs/resource/2de80207-ae46-4955-8adb-9eee0c89febb"",""descValue"":""Bus Geolocated Lines, Stops and Stop times""},{""urlValue"":""http://data.rio/dataset/gps-de-onibus/resource/cfeb367c-c1c3-4fa7-b742-65c2c99d8d90"",""descValue"":""Bus GPS real-time location""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the amount of links provided is due to the fact that maps are provided per transportation mode. Schedule information was only available explicitly for ferry boats. For buses, information on GPS real-time location was provided, but not a schedule. For Subway, VLT, BRT and Train, only itineraries and stations were found. Data is incomplete for Subway (the new Line 4 is missing).""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","65","65"
"cbcc42d3-0280-4d02-a7bf-52b9a5d5f623","br-cities","2017-02-03T16:27:22","2017","rj","crime","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The information is provided monthly. The last information available is from december 2016.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""At the footer they declare to have a “Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Brasil” license""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled “number” and “rio de janeiro” and “robbery”  or  “muders” or “rapes” or “firearm seizures” and the ISP website came up among the first results. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.creativecommons.org.br/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is not clear which license among those indicated creative commons website is the one of this portal. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I consider a extensive effort because of the number of datasets you have to download and consolidate to finally analyse and compare different areas, months and rates. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""ISP - Instituto de Segurança Pública"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Portuguese for Public Security Institute. ISP is a state level administration body. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Number of robbery"",""Number of murder"",""Number of rapes"",""Firearm seizures"",""Data available per neighborhood or equivalent""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The institute provides the data per “police unit” which is  the territorial delimitation applied in Brazil’s public security logistic.  It is defined by the area which a police  station is responsible for.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""Public Security Institute"",""descValue"":""http://www.isp.rj.gov.br/Conteudo.asp?ident=108 ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","Yes","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"e610b6ac-e764-4c62-92e2-b3704325c993","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:01:17","2017","rj","weather","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is not downloadable., but can be viewed on the web. You can download the historical/current registers, but not the forecasts. These historical series provide information on precipitation amount, average temperature and wind speed. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The forecasts are not downloadable in any format, but they can be viewed on the web and you can copy and paste the content, that's why I selected HTML. Historical data is provided in .TXT. ""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is provided for the current day and the next four days, as demanded by the methodology.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""When I first tried to google for “weather forecast in Rio de Janeiro”, I got only national references (like INPE and INMET) and private websites (like Climatempo). The only one from the city of Rio de Janeiro was the “Centro de Operações Rio”, a weather monitoring center in the city. The website was outdated though. So, I had to ask for a specialist where was the best source of this data in Rio. So I got the reference for Alerta Rio. I would not have associated “alert” with “weather forecast” before.""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""When I first tried to google for “weather forecast in Rio de Janeiro”, I got only national references (like INPE and INMET) and private websites (like Climatempo). The only one from the city of Rio de Janeiro was the “Centro de Operações Rio”, a weather monitoring center in the city. The website was outdated though. So, I had to ask for a specialist where was the best source of this data in Rio. So I got the reference for Alerta Rio. I would not have associated “alert” with “weather forecast” before.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I googled “weather forecast in Rio de Janeiro”, 2) I didn’t find a reference from the city, only the monitoring center for extreme events, 3) I didn’t find the up-to-date information in open data format in this website, 4) I consulted with a specialist to ask for a reference and the answer was to look for “Alerta Rio”, 5) I went to Alerta Rio website and found it to be the best source of weather information in the city by the government."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://alertario.rio.rj.gov.br/institucional/termos-de-uso/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is the terms of use of the data, stating that it is public. There is no specific license mentioned.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is not downloadable in any format. So it is difficult to process it and make analysis.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Fundação Instituto de Geotécnica (Geo-Rio)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided at the website of “Alerta Rio”, maintained by Geo-Rio foundation, a geotechnical foundation associated to the municipal secretariat of construction.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes"",""Wind direction"",""Forecast for current day and four following days""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The information for the current day (http://alertario.rio.rj.gov.br/24-horas/) is separated from the next four days (http://alertario.rio.rj.gov.br/4-dias/). Forecasts doesn’t provide objective information on temperature averages, wind speed, precipitation amount and precipitation probability, just general status like “weak, moderated” or “cloudy, partly cloudy”.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://alertario.rio.rj.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""The website of “Alerta Rio”, a online platform for emergency control for meteorological conditions, specially heavy rain that can cause landslides. It contains data for weather forecast in the city of Rio de Janeiro.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.","Historical data is also provided in the open data portal of the city of Rio de Janeiro (Datario) in the links below, but it is outdated.
http://data.rio/dataset/dados-meteorologicos
http://data.rio/dataset/registros-de-pluviometros","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"abc7dda3-4bbb-4635-9afa-4096b307ea04","br-cities","2017-04-26T19:30:23","2017","rj","land","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":""IPP is a municipal government institute linked to Rio’s Urban Planning Bureau, and it is responsible for the official Cartography and Municipal Geoprocessing of the city. The dataset required was not found, though."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. This dataset was resubmitted because the one offered in the first submission didn't qualify for the evaluation","This dataset was resubmitted because the one offered in the first submission didn't qualify for the evaluation","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","0","0"
"c9ba4972-f6d9-4466-88f8-914da8d2793d","br-cities","2017-02-02T14:20:13","2017","rj","emissions","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is not downloadable.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable, but it can be viewed on the web. You can also copy and paste the data in a spreadsheet, for example.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated everyday around 4 p.m.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""When I tried to search for pollutant emissions in Rio de Janeiro I couldn't find it, but because of the experience filling the national survey, I knew that if I searched for \""air quality\"" I would find it more easily.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I looked at google for \""Air Quality Rio de Janeiro\"", 2) I found the link for the MonitorAr project; 3) I checked with a specialist to see if that was the best source."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://prefeitura.rio/politica-de-privacidade"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no specific license for the air quality data, but all content from the Rio de Janeiro City Hall website is under a Creative Commons Attribution License 3.0 in accordance with the link. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some effort is necessary to understand the specifics of this kind of data. You also need to copy and paste the information in a machine-readable format in order to further work with this data. So I consider it very difficult to use data, even though it is available everyday for consultation.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""SMAC/RJ - Secretaria Municipal de Meio Ambiente da Prefeitura da Cidade do Rio de Janeiro"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided by a project called \""MonitorAr-Rio\"", an agreement between the City Hall of Rio de Janeiro, through its Environment Secretariat with the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro and Petrobras, the brazilian state-owned petroleum company. Data can be obtained through the Environment Secretariat (SMAC) link.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data was available for all the pollutants required except VOCs, per air monitoring station. There are nine in the city of Rio de Janeiro, eight fixed and one mobile. The mobile one had no data due to temporary relocation.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://smac.infoper.net/smac/boletim"",""descValue"":""The link goes directly to the most recent report on air quality provided by the Environment Secretariat of the city of Rio de Janeiro. ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is a web-based report, where you can access the most recent or past reports. Data is not available for download.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"fd5ca19f-8b14-4d9c-b3c0-57908a8191d6","br-cities","2017-02-02T18:16:34","2017","rj","boundaries","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It is hard to find the specific website's section where the data is.\n""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Once in IBGE's website you go to downloads section, click in \""Geociências\"" (Geoscience), choose the files: organização_do_territorio (territory organization)> malhas_territoriais (territory modal)> malhas_municipais (municipal modal) > município_2015 > UFs and choose RJ You need a lot of clicks to get the file"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/disseminacao/eventos/missao/principios_fundamentais_orientacoes_divulgacoes.shtm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" or a real license, but I found at this link a list of fundamental principles for official statistics with some guidelines for publication and dissemination. It contains the idea of data provided for public domain.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You should have some knowledge on geographic datasets in order to work with this (including knowledge in geographic softwares).""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística - IBGE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Portuguese for Brazilian Geography and Statistics Institute ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://downloads.ibge.gov.br/downloads_geociencias.htm"",""descValue"":""Brazilian Geography and Statistics Institute (Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística - IBGE)""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/c457e8eef54f44e2acf18c148cf1731c_14"",""descValue"":""Pereira Passos Institute""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Both of them provide Rio de Janeiro administrative boundaries. Although, the IBGE shapefile is more granular, so we will use it as reference for this evaluation. \n""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","Yes","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"290f31fc-1d1c-41a5-ab26-233691c8aa30","br-cities","2017-02-02T14:34:44","2017","rj","postcodes","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Zipcodes are not available.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""DBF"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""GeoJSON files can be downloaded through the “API” link. Shapefile extensions are also available in .CPG and .PRJ. Spreadsheet comes directly in .CSV.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is a statement in the webpage saying that it was updated 2 months ago.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It was not very easy to find this map, even though I’m acquainted with this platform. It took me some time to realize that I had to click on the search button without a query in order to get the full list of datasets and then search for the location dataset I was looking for. A specialist in the area helped me finding it.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I looked at the website of many different sources from Rio de Janeiro’s City Hall, but I had trouble finding the correct link. I consulted with a specialist for help. Finally, when I came to the link above, I downloaded it but I couldn’t understand very well what kind of data was there, so I came to the specialist again to help me figure out the content of the dataset."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/3b251e4dce6a441ba01f9f8f8826640f_22"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The same link for the map above also displays a license in the footer. It is a Open Database License. It also has a mention to “public use” of the data at the same link.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are many formats in which data are available, but you should have some knowledge on geographic datasets in order to work with this (including knowledge in geographic softwares).""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IPP - Instituto Pereira Passos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The Pereira Passos Institute (IPP) is the research department for Rio de Janeiro's City Government, responsible for collecting data, strategic planning and public policies integration, mapping, cartographic production and geotechnology application.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""When I downloaded the spreadsheet available, I could get the information by addresses for the entire city, but I couldn’t get zipcodes and coordinates. However, the specialist I consulted said the last column, “shape_length”, had the intrinsic coordinates that could be accessed through a GIS software, if I downloaded it in shapefile format. So I considered that this information is available. Zipcodes are not available though.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/3b251e4dce6a441ba01f9f8f8826640f_22"",""descValue"":""Link for the geolocated dataset for Rio de Janeiro’s locations.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link goes directly to a map hosted in IPP’s open geodata website.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Changed B5 to No because zipcodes were not available.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"6b4ab56f-f62d-4ada-a356-6a1131834077","br-cities","2017-02-02T20:48:41","2017","rj","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no API, so you don’t have access to the complete dataset. You have to build queries specifying the kind of legislation you are interested in. ""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Rio de Janeiro City council is under recess in this month, so I can't check the update frequency during the current legislation period. Based on the last legislation period, the lastest bills proposed were published at the website in less than a week from the day of proposition. ""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is no license declaration in the website. Regarding the definition of copyright content stated by the Law 9.610/1998 in Article 7, XIII, a dataset will be copyrightable only if its organization involves an intellectual creation. In this case, data is primary or factual, so we can assume that it is open or public.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You type \""propostas lei municipais Rio de Janeiro\"" - portuguese for \""municipal draft laws Rio de Janeiro\""  and the first option is  the city council website. Once there you click in \""Matérias Legislativas\"", portuguese for \""Legislation Matter\"" in the homepage's menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can’t download data, so to get the information you need you have to look for it in the website. At the same time,  there is a basic search mechanism where you can  set some characteristics of the proposition you are lookinng for.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Rio de Janeiro City council (Câmara dos Vereadores)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of the city council"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The information about votes per member of parliament is at the transcripts of sessions. \n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.camara.rj.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""Rio de Janeiro City Council""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"d95bd2bc-04e5-43da-92a7-abe4f2dad35e","br-cities","2017-02-02T18:03:34","2017","rj","statistics","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In the case of GDP the last dataset available is from 2013.  For unemployment the data is  available every 3 months and is up to date. For Population the last dataset available is from 2015 July.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""For GDP and Population, I just googled those keywords and \""municipal\"". For Unemployment,  I did a quick research to check if the Continuous National Household Sample Survey collects municipal data.  After that I visited the IBGE website and searched for Population, GDP and Unemployment at the municipal level"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/disseminacao/eventos/missao/principios_fundamentais_orientacoes_divulgacoes.shtm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" or a real license, but I found at this link a list of fundamental principles for official statistics with some guidelines for publication and dissemination. It contains the idea of data provided for public domain.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Datasets are downloadable in a processable format. Also it is easy to understand how data is organized.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IBGE - Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Portuguese for Brazilian institute for geography and statistics""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""City unemployment"",""City population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/pesquisas/pesquisa_resultados.php?id_pesquisa=46"",""descValue"":""Municipal Gross Domestic Product - IBGE""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/indicadores/trabalhoerendimento/pnad_continua_mensal/default.shtm "",""descValue"":""Quarterly unemployment rates from the Continuous National Household Sample Survey - IBGE""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/populacao/estimativa2015/estimativa_dou.shtm"",""descValue"":""Municipal Population Estimatives - IBGE""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.sidra.ibge.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""All data from IBGE can also be downloaded through this system called SIDRA. But here you don't have access to the whole dataset.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","B6 was reviewed because GDP was not updated. Reviewed.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","85","85"
"0f06a70c-8341-4063-bf2c-20c8843a4937","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:36:36","2017","rj","map","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":"" In all IPP’s weblinks you can download the data by theme in a zip file.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""GeoJSON"",""KML"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""most of the data has been updated within the last year.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""all the information from IPP is under Open data license. As it says every time I select something to download, like in this link: http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/8454eb0454b7424d89c61b67742286a1_15 ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""since i know IPP is responsible for maps and geolocation data from Rio de Janeiro’s city  it was easy from that point on. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""i googled IPP maps and  IPP shapefile and got the links i needed it"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""if i google \""geodata rio\""  IPPs open source platform is the first one on the list, so, i suppose it's easy to get the data.""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/66c416fb22b74945883e289f35a6590e_0 "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the link is an example, at the footer there is information about open source license that's in every dataset download page.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""IPP’s open data geo website has a search engine, which helps, the whole website is really easy to navigate. http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/ ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IPP- Instituto Pereira Passos"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""IPP  is a municipal government institute linked to Rio’s  Urban Planning Bureau, and it is responsible for the official Cartography and Municipal Geoprocessing of the city.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""City borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can get a map with the scale 1:10,000 of the whole city - which is bigger then 1:250,000, so I that's why I considered it checked.  I was able to download data from \nSub Basins, so i checked the water stretches map. I can also get data from several ways the city is divided in a public policy kind of way, from neighborhood to policy watch areas, and so on, also markings and reliefs. The only problem i got was on downloading  \""markings of national traffic routes\"", i was able to find only through both Universities websites i linked before.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.rio.rj.gov.br/web/ipp/exibeconteudo?id=4477445 "",""descValue"":""In this link i have access to Rio’s Cartographic Collection and Digital plants.""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.rio.rj.gov.br/amdados800.asp?gtema=15"",""descValue"":""The “armazem de dados” roughly translated to data warehouse is IPP’s repository and there is a option to look for digital maps.""},{""urlValue"":""http://portalgeo.pcrj.opendata.arcgis.com/"",""descValue"":""Open data platform on geolocation data from IPP""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.professores.uff.br/cristiane/Estudodirigido/Caso%20Localizacao%20Empreendimento.htm "",""descValue"":""Universidade Federal Fluminense, a Federal University that is located in Niteroi city, has a geoprocessing center and it has some data on Rio's city map available. ""},{""urlValue"":""http://gis.coppe.ufrj.br/tcw/index.html "",""descValue"":""Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro also  has some data on Rio’s city maps.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","Yes","Bárbara Barbosa","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"38aefb2d-c9c0-4f47-990e-bdfc739c0937","br-cities","2017-02-02T14:15:59","2017","rj","elections","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are plenty of different datasets, depending on what kind of data is needed. They are usually downloaded via ZIP file containing a text file per unit established in the dataset choice. Inside it you have one .TXT file per federate state. In each of these files you have all municipalities from that state. You just have to look for Rio de Janeiro in this case.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data for 2016 Mayoral Elections was available one day after the counting process took place.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is public and regulated by the brazilian law of access to information (http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm), but there is no specific open license for electoral data.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data, since I’ve been working with them recently, so it was really easy to me. But if you search “Eleições resultados”, portuguese for “Election Results” in google, the first links are those from TSE.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I knew before that TSE was responsible for Election Results data, so I just went to TSE webpage (http://www.tse.jus.br/), 2) I searched the menu \""Elections\"" and then \""Elections Statistics\"", 3) I clicked the link for \""Election Data Repository\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/repositorio-de-dados-eleitorais"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link is the same of the homepage of the Electoral Data Repository from TSE. The text shows its public use intention, but there is no specific license for it. The information is regulated by the brazilian Law of Access to Information, as shown above, and because of that, it is considered public. This link (http://dados.gov.br/dataset/resultado-das-eleicoes/resource/bfd28046-7236-4a4a-82ef-3e0fcd92771c) shows that there is no specific license.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some effort is required, since data is provided encoded. But all files come with a read-me file containing the correspondence between codes and descriptions.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""TSE - Tribunal Superior Eleitoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Mayoral elections data, just like national elections, is collected by the Brazilian Superior Electoral Court (TSE), the highest judiciary institution in Brazil for electoral issues.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for mayoral elections"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I suppose that all the information required is the same as the Global Index requires, the only difference is that in this case it should be available for the municipality level, the mayoral elections: mayors and city councilmen.\n1) Mayoral Contests are available at the same platform as National Contests. For example: 2016 we had Municipal Contests and 2014, National Contests. Both happen every 4 years.\n2) One of the datasets available is \""Detalhe da apuração por município e zona\"" (Counting detail per municipality and electoral ward), which shows the total number of registered votes per municipality and electoral ward.\n3) The number of invalid votes can be obtained in the same dataset above. This dataset also includes abstentions.\n4) In Brazil, the voting process takes place with electronic ballot boxes. So, it doesn't makes sense to have spoiled ballots data, but the number of invalid votes from subjury ballot boxes can be obtained through the same dataset above. Those are invalid votes until a electoral judge decides if they are actually valid or nullified. \n5) The \""Detalhe da apuração por seção eleitoral\"" (Counting detail per electoral section) dataset shows data per polling station (ballot box).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/repositorio-de-dados-eleitorais"",""descValue"":""Main page for all brazilian election data (Repositório de dados eleitorais, which means Election Data Repository). The session \""results\"" in the left panel shows election results since 1945.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Here there is the general link for the TSE webpage. There are no specific links to get the information required for the dataset, but they are accessible through navigation. First, you choose the year and then you select what kind of dataset you need. In the case of Rio de Janeiro, a city, we are probably interested in mayoral elections, which take place every four years. We had one in 2016, so before that we had in 2012, 2008 and so forth.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok",,"Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"c4257cc7-4aca-420b-b7e9-a796e3e4a231","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:06:57","2017","rj","spending","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Even though there is a full dataset available for downloading, it doesn’t contain all the information required and it is not by individual transaction. In other words, it is more aggregated than it should be. So I considered that the dataset is not downloadable at once, because to get the information required you need to navigate and then download a specific query of the dataset.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TXT"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""You can download in these formats, even though the dataset is not complete. It is also available in .RTF format.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated daily and the date of the last update is very visible in the webpage.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I’m very acquainted with this kind of data. And it is easy to find through google if you search for “transparency spending rio de janeiro”. You can also find it easily through the main website of the City Hall (http://prefeitura.rio/)""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I knew it before that Rio Transparente was the main platform for government spending data in the city of Rio de Janeiro, so I just had to enter the website and search for the information required."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://riotransparente.rio.rj.gov.br/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""At the webpage footer there is a mention to a Creative Commons Attribution License 2.0.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some effort is required because even though the data is machine readable, the full dataset doesn’t contain all the information. Also, you have to understand the budget classification in order to correctly analyze data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Controladoria Geral do Município do Rio de Janeiro (CGM-RJ)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided through a platform called “Rio Transparente”, provided by the Municipal General Comptroller of Rio de Janeiro.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not all information in available when you download the .txt file through the “open data” tab. But if you navigate, for example, in “expenditures per vendor” (Despesas por favorecido), you can find all the information with many clicks. In the end, you can download a file with the extraction you generated. The last table brings information on the date of the transaction, an individual ID for the payment order, the program to which this expenditure is associated, the number of the process and the amount of the transaction. The name of the vendor and the government office which had the transaction appear not in the table, but just over it.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://riotransparente.rio.rj.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""Transparency platform for government spending in Rio de Janeiro, created and maintained by the Municipal General Comptroller.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"900964d4-ab2c-43b6-84f3-57e345657c8a","br-cities","2017-04-18T21:42:01","2017","sp","water","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no historical series of data, only the last report.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""PDF""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""the data comes in a PDF format report only.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The department says on its homepage that it is a monthly report, but the last one is from September. The survey is being done late december.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no license to use and no information that the data is public on the site.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I found the data just by putting in google a phrase (qualidade de água na cidade de são paulo) about the information.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled “qualidade de água na cidade de são paulo” (Water quality in São Paulo city). I was directed by google to the site of the Municipal Health Department (http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/saude/vigilancia_em_saude/saude_ambiental/agua/index.php?p=6967). At the left of the homepage, we have a link with the word “water”. When you click at the word, it opens the VIGIAGUA portal. When you are at VIGIAGUA you have to click at “Veja aqui os resultados das últimas análises!”  Than a PDF file opens with the last report."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data comes in PDF and to use them you must convert from PDF format to an editable format.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria Municipal de Saúde de São Paulo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Fecal coliform"",""Nitrates"",""Available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The information comes in PDF per administrative district in São Paulo, but not per water source. Fecal coliform information comes described as “E.coli” and “Termotolerant bacteria”.\n""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/saude/vigilancia_em_saude/saude_ambiental/agua/index.php?p=6967"",""descValue"":""VIGIAGUA aims to monitor the quality of water for human consumption in the city of São Paulo, as well as to detect situations of health risk related to its consumption.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Revision ok.","Submission made by Janaina fernandes","Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","35","35"
"282c14c5-e5eb-44fa-a8f1-70a536253dc2","br-cities","2017-02-03T17:22:59","2017","sp","crime","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""First of all, data related to murder, rape and robbery appears in one part of the website, while firearm seizures in another. Also, in both cases you have to download data by police units. So you have to download lots of databasis to consolidate the required information in one dataset. \n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is no license declaration in the website. Regarding the definition of copyright content stated by the Law 9.610/1998 in Article 7, XIII, a dataset will be copyrightable only if its organization involves an intellectual creation. In this case, data is primary or factual, so we can assume that it is open or public. \n""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It was easy to find the website where the data is. But it was hard to find the desired information at the website. The search mechanism is not good.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled “são paulo”, “municipal”, “roubo” and  “dados”, portuguese for “são paulo” “municipal” “robbery” and “data”. The first option was the Public Security Secretary where all the information required is hosted (including “rape,” “firearm seizures” and “muders”). However, it will not be so easy to find this website if instead of “robbery”, we insert “rape”, “firearm seizures” or “muders”. In those cases it will come as first results a lot of news websites instead of the website where the primary information is. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I consider a extensive effort because of the number of datasets you have to download and consolidate to finally analyse and compare different areas, months and rates. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria da Segurança Pública"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Portuguese for Public Security Secretary, a state administration body. \n""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Number of robbery"",""Number of murder"",""Number of rapes"",""Firearm seizures"",""Data available per neighborhood or equivalent""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The institute provides the data per “police unit” which is  the territorial delimitation applied in Brazil’s public security logistic.  It is defined by the area which a police  station is responsible for.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.ssp.sp.gov.br/Estatistica/Pesquisa.aspx"",""descValue"":""Public Security Secretary""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","80","80"
"6becb9d8-4f20-4dd7-9340-0fbdb7e9cfff","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:54:41","2017","sp","weather","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is not downloadable. You can only visualize it on the web.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The forecasts are not available in any format for download.  But you view it on the web and copy and paste content. So .HTML format was considered.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Even though data is always provided for the current day, it is not provided for the next four days as demanded by the methodology.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn’t find any license or statement, terms and conditions, nothing in the website.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""When I first tried to google for “weather forecast in São Paulo”, I got only national references (like INPE and INMET) and private websites (like Climatempo). Based on prior knowledge obtained filling the survey for Rio de Janeiro, I tried to search for a emergency control center and I found CGE’s website.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I googled “weather forecast in São Paulo”, 2) I didn’t find a government reference from the city, 3) I searched for a emergency control center and I found CGE’s website, 4) I found it to be the best source of weather information in the city by the government."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is not downloadable in any format. So it is difficult to process it and make analysis.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Centro de Gerenciamento de Emergências (CGE) da Prefeitura de São Paulo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided at the website of CGE, maintained by São Paulo’s City Hall. It is a agency responsible for monitoring of meteorological conditions in the city.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Temperature extremes""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The website contains information only for the current day and two following days, and only for temperature extremes, humidity, and a “qualitative” probability of rain based on a “storm potential” being “low, moderated or high”. No data is provided on temperature average, wind speed and direction or precipitation amount and probability (objective).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.cgesp.org/v3/previsao_estendida.jsp"",""descValue"":""The website of CGE, a online platform for emergency control for meteorological conditions. This link goes directly to the weather forecast in the city of São Paulo.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","55","55"
"e74e48b3-5f71-44f4-86bc-b963398b32b7","br-cities","2017-02-02T20:48:23","2017","sp","procurement","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""XLS"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""At the moment this survey is being completed (feb/2017), the latest data available to download stops at november 2016""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" if i google “procurement open data são paulo” i get both webpages easily. and the third one is linked in the firts one.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""i googled procurement open data são paulo city, found the pages above and downloaded the files to check information."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/base-de-compras-e-licitacoes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""on the bar on the left side there’s a link to the open license (Creative Commons CC Zero) http://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero/""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""São Paulo City Hall - Prefeitura de São Paulo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The city hall open data webpage makes it available info on São Paulo’s city government budget, including procurement data.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Tenders per government office"",""Awards per government office"",""Tender name"",""Tender description"",""Tender status"",""Award title"",""Award description"",""Value of the award"",""Supplier's name""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://transparencia.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/contas/Paginas/ComprasLicitacoes.aspx"",""descValue"":""public transparency São Paulo ""},{""urlValue"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/base-de-compras-e-licitacoes "",""descValue"":""open data webpage""},{""urlValue"":""http://e-negocioscidadesp.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""City Hall Business webpage""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Bárbara Barbosa","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","85","85"
"b111bf7b-de09-402f-bbff-48a8f5a9b5ac","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:30:32","2017","sp","emissions","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The dataset is downloadable through Qualar system, but you have to choose some extractions (station and pollutant). So, not available in bulk.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""you can only get this format through the Qualar system.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is updated hourly.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Downloadable data is only available after registering in a system called “Qualar”. You can view data without registering, though, but you are not able to download it.""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn’t find any license or statement, terms and conditions, nothing in the website. And I had to register to download data.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It was quite easy to find the data, even for someone not acquainted with the topic. I just had to type “air quality data são paulo” in google and then navigate through the website.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I first tried to find something at the São Paulo open data portal but couldn’t find information on air quality, 2) Then I looked at google for \""Air Quality Data São Paulo”, 3) I found the link for CETESB webpage and navigated through to find the information."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some effort is necessary to understand the specifics of this kind of data and to create a full databank with all the information, since you can only download parts of the data, not all of it at once. At least there is a machine readable format in this case.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""CETESB - Companhia Ambiental do Estado de São Paulo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is provided by a state government agency in São Paulo whose name, roughly translated is “São Paulo State Environmental Company”.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Particulate matter (PM)"",""Sulphur oxides (SOx)"",""Nitrogen oxides (NOx)"",""Carbon monoxide (CO)"",""Ozone"",""Available per air monitoring station/zone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data was available for all the pollutants required except VOCs, per air monitoring station. There are twenty-six in the São Paulo Metropolitan Region. Data on particulate matter are provided under two designations: inhalable particles and small/fine inhalable particles.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://ar.cetesb.sp.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""The link goes to the “air quality” webpage of CETESB. At the blue header, at the “air quality” option, you have many different options to access the data.""},{""urlValue"":""http://sistemasinter.cetesb.sp.gov.br/Ar/php/boletim_por_poluente.php"",""descValue"":""This link shows the latest available data per station and per pollutant.""},{""urlValue"":""http://sistemasinter.cetesb.sp.gov.br/Ar/php/mapa_qualidade_rmsp.php"",""descValue"":""This link shows a map of São Paulo’s city metropolitan region with the situation of each station.""},{""urlValue"":""http://sistemasinter.cetesb.sp.gov.br/Ar/php/ar_dados_horarios.php"",""descValue"":""This link provides hourly data per station in tables.""},{""urlValue"":""http://qualar.cetesb.sp.gov.br/qualar/home.do"",""descValue"":""This link is a system provided by CETESB that permits downloading data per station in .csv.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""They are all web-based reports except the last one that has a function “export data”.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","55","55"
"3dde6a43-f9c7-4889-938b-bc5a91471ef4","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:47:27","2017","sp","boundaries","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""the file also comes in .PRJ format which is not on the list.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data are updated since it is already possible to plot the new urban zoning plan of São Paulo that was revised in June 2016 (Zoning – Municipal Law 16,402 / 16)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I found the data just by putting in google a phrase (mapa da cidade de são paulo formato aberto) about the information.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled “mapa cidade de são paulo formato aberto” (Map of the city of São Paulo open format). I was directed by google to the site of the Municipal Department of Urban Development (http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/desenvolvimento_urbano/dados_estatisticos/)  and at the top of the page of the site had a link to the portal GeoSampa."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"" http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/desenvolvimento_urbano/dados_estatisticos/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link for GeoSampa website advise that: The GeoSampa portal gathers detailed and georeferenced public information about the municipality, offering data availability in open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data comes in an open format (shapefile) that can be used in different programs and easy to read even in free softwares like QGis.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria Municipal de Desenvolvimento Urbano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Comment: The GeoSampa portal is hosted within the website of the Municipal Department of Urban Development of the Municipality of São Paulo. The Secretariat is the city's governing body responsible for urban planning. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Boundary level 1"",""Boundary level 2"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Name of poligone (department, region, city)"",""Borders of poligone""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The map comes in shapefile and dbf format, it is possible to add different layers ranging from urban infrastructure to hydrography and it can be plotted on different scales. The map can be plotted at different scales due to the possibility of downloading in shapefile.\nThere is a menu of options to the right of the site where you can choose the layer with the information you want:\n Boundary level 1 (camadas - Limites Administrativos – Distrito)\nBoundary level 2 (camadas - Limites Administrativos – subprefeitura)\nCoordinates (latitude, longitude) (the format is shapefile, when you make the download the latitude and longitude comes together)\nName of poligone (department, region, city) (camadas - Limites Administrativos)\nBorders of poligone (camadas - Limites Administrativos)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://geosampa.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/PaginasPublicas/_SBC.aspx#"",""descValue"":""GeoSampa gathers detailed and georeferenced information about the municipality, offering data available in an open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GeoSampa gathers detailed and georeferenced information about the municipality, offering data available in an open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","Yes","janaina fernandes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"da59273e-561b-4d80-b602-8e42d917afbe","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:47:00","2017","sp","postcodes","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Shapefile extensions are also available in .PRJ.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data from 2016 was available and updated in september.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn’t find any license or statement, terms and conditions, nothing in the website.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""it took me some time analyzing data provided in the São Paulo Open Data Portal, the second link provided above. Finally, I realized it was outdated, so I looked for a updated one. When I typed “public places data são paulo” I found the website for the CEM, the first link provided, with the updated information.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I first looked at the open data portal; 2) I found the information there (checking with a specialist if it was right), but it was outdated; 3) So I googled “public places dataset são paulo city” and i found CEM’s website; 4) I just had to download the dataset and check if it had the information needed."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are many formats in which data are available, but you should have some knowledge on geographic datasets in order to work with this (including knowledge in geographic softwares).""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""CEM - Centro de Estudos da Metrópole"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The “CEM” (Center for metropolitan studies, roughly translated) is a research institution on social sciences applied to metropolitan areas based in the University of São Paulo and CEBRAP (Brazilian Center for Analysis and Planning).""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Zipcodes"",""Addresses"",""Coordinates (latitude, longitude)"",""Data available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""When I downloaded the .rar file, it had many files inside, including a read-me file. With this one I could check that addresses and zipcodes for the entire city were available. For the coordinates, the specialist I consulted opened the file with a GIS software and showed me that there was implicit information that could provide latitude and longitude. So, I considered that it has this information, even though it was not explicit in the documentation.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.fflch.usp.br/centrodametropole/716"",""descValue"":""This link provides a download for the 2016 locations dataset for the São Paulo Metropolitan Region.""},{""urlValue"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/geocodificacao-de-logradouros-geolog"",""descValue"":""Data is also available in the São Paulo city Open Data Portal, but it is outdated.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In the first link, you have to scroll down a little bit and click on “Base de Logradouros-2016”, obtaining a .rar file (zipped format with many files).""}]","Yes","Yes","Municipal open data portal also provides the locations dataset with all the information required. It is not updated, though. So, the dataset considered is this one from USP. Review ok.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","90","90"
"2c023b3a-094e-4de5-a232-96955a24542a","br-cities","2017-02-03T17:17:40","2017","sp","draftlegislation","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is an API available if you want to get all the dataset.\n""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""I couldn’t find a specific license for the entire website, although there is an open data section where you can access the information available at the website.\n""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I consider it easy because a search in google returns the specific website where data is primarily. Also because the website is well organized, so it is easy to find the desired information on it. ""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You type \""propostas lei municipais São Paulo\"" - portuguese for \""municipal draft laws São Paulo\""  and the first option is  the city council website. Once there you click in \""Atividade Legislativa\"", portuguese for \""Legislative Activity\"" in the homepage's menu."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.camara.sp.gov.br/transparencia/dados-abertos/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You do not get all this information consolidated in a dataset ready for analyse it.  If you want to get this information about a bill, for example, you would first have to search for the bill (where you would get content, author, status and votes) and then looki for the transcripts of debates that occurred in the plenary session of the day when the bill was voted. \nYou could use the API as well, but for that you would need some basic knowledge in programming to deal with it.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" São Paulo City council (Câmara dos Vereadores)"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of bill"",""Author of bill"",""Votes on bill per member of the city council"",""Transcripts of debates on bill"",""Status of bill""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Once in the council website, you go in “Legislative Activity” where you can find all this information in different ways. In “sessão plenária”portuguese for plenary session, you can search for the proposed bills (content, author and status), votes (by day or by bill)  and also transcripts of debates by day (not by bill).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.camara.sp.gov.br/atividade-legislativa/splegis-consulta/"",""descValue"":""São Paulo City Council ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","The license for open data is pretty ok for this case. Everything else reviewed and it's ok.",,"Yes","Yes","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"125f8aac-3f86-4468-9514-3474bf628333","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:24:06","2017","sp","statistics","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""TSV"",""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":"".csv and .tsv formats are available in any query generated through SIDRA (http://www.sidra.ibge.gov.br/).""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In the case of GDP the last dataset available is from 2013. \nFor unemployment the data is available every 3 months and is up to date. \nFor Population the last dataset available is from 2015 July.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data, since I’ve been working with them for a long time, so it was really easy to me. But actually, finding data in IBGE’s website may not be that easy. Data is scattered through the website in many different places and you can actually find the same data in different ways.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""For GDP and Population, I just had to type in google those keywords and \""municipal\"". For Unemployment,  I did a quick research to check if the Continuous National Household Sample Survey collects municipal data.  After that I visited the IBGE website and searched for Population, GDP and Unemployment at the municipal level."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/disseminacao/eventos/missao/principios_fundamentais_orientacoes_divulgacoes.shtm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" or a real license, but I found at this link a list of fundamental principles for official statistics with some guidelines for publication and dissemination. It contains the idea of data provided for public domain.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no API but you can download the whole dataset at once in  processable format. Data is organized in sheets, so you don’t have to clean it to work.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IBGE - Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The brazilian institute for geography and statistics is a federal government agency, associated with the brazilian ministry of planning, budget and management (Ministério do Planejamento, Orçamento e Gestão). The federal institute collects data in municipal level as well. ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product"",""City unemployment"",""City population""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/pesquisas/pesquisa_resultados.php?id_pesquisa=46"",""descValue"":""Municipal Gross Domestic Product - IBGE ""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/indicadores/trabalhoerendimento/pnad_continua_mensal/default.shtm "",""descValue"":""Quarterly unemployment rates from the Continuous National Household Sample Survey - IBGE""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/estatistica/populacao/estimativa2015/estimativa_dou.shtm"",""descValue"":""Municipal Population Estimates - IBGE ""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.sidra.ibge.gov.br/"",""descValue"":""All data from IBGE can also be downloaded through this system called SIDRA. But here you don't have access to the whole dataset.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Revised. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","85","85"
"22e0fc7f-8555-40b6-85a8-b8586a666e1e","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:40:42","2017","sp","map","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""the file also comes in .PRJ format which is not on the list.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The data are updated since it is already possible to plot the new urban zoning plan of São Paulo that was revised in June 2016 (Zoning – Municipal Law 16,402 / 16)""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I found the data just by putting in google a sentence (mapa da cidade de são paulo formato aberto) about the information.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I googled “mapa cidade de são paulo formato aberto” (Map of the city of São Paulo open format). I was directed by google to the site of the Municipal Department of Urban Development (http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/desenvolvimento_urbano/dados_estatisticos/)  and at the top of the page of the site there was a link to the portal GeoSampa."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/desenvolvimento_urbano/dados_estatisticos/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link for GeoSampa website advise that: The GeoSampa portal gathers detailed and georeferenced public information about the municipality, offering data availability in open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data comes in an open format (shapefile) that can be used in different programs and easy to read even in free softwares like QGis.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria Municipal de Desenvolvimento Urbano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The GeoSampa portal is hosted within the website of the Municipal Department of Urban Development of the Municipality of São Paulo. The Secretariat is the city's governing body responsible for urban planning.  ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""City borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The map comes in shapefile and dbf format, it is possible to add different layers ranging from urban infrastructure to hydrography and it can be plotted on different scales. The map can be plotted at different scales (including the one required) due to the possibility of downloading in shapefile.\nThere is a menu of options to the right of the site where you can choose the layer with the information you want: \nMarkings of national traffic routes (Sistema viário)\nMarkings of relief/heightss (Meio físico – topografia)\nMarkings of water stretches (Meio físico – hidrografia)\nNational borders (Limites administrativos)""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://geosampa.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/PaginasPublicas/_SBC.aspx#"",""descValue"":""GeoSampa gathers detailed and georeferenced information about the municipality, offering data available in an open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall.  ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""GeoSampa gathers detailed and georeferenced information about the municipality, offering data available in an open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall.""}]","Yes","Yes","Revised. Everything ok.",,"Yes","Yes","janaina fernandes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"dd6f43b3-dcb2-4163-a669-a1fa294cb5f3","br-cities","2017-02-03T16:44:37","2017","sp","budget","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Also ODS""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""They present information by year.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A quick search in google will present the right website where the information is. Once in the website, it is easy to find the desired information""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You type \""loa sp município\"" which means “São Paulo anual budget law” in google and the first option will be  the city hall open data website. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" There is no license declaration in the website. Regarding the definition of copyright content stated by the Law 9.610/1998 in Article 7, XIII, a dataset will be copyrightable only if its organization involves an intellectual creation. In this case, data is primary or factual, so we can assume that it is open or public. ""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can download all data in once in a editable format, so it is quite simple to analyse it and take conclusions. ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" http://capital.sp.gov.br/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""São Paulo city hall""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can download the approved budget per year, government department and sub-department and other budgetary classifications.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://transparencia.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/contas/Paginas/LeiOrcamentoAnual.aspx"",""descValue"":""City hall open data website ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Dataset reviewed.
Even though information is also provided through the API system (https://api.prodam.sp.gov.br/store/apis/info?name=SOF&version=v2.1.0&provider=admin), this dataset used is more comprehensive in terms of budget and presented less problems with usability.",,"Yes","Yes","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"da976582-3d63-4d58-a9e4-9ab8df943c34","br-cities","2017-02-03T17:15:22","2017","sp","law","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There is an API available if you want to get all the dataset.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML"",""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""A quick search in google will present the right website where the information is. Once in the website, it is easy to find the desired information.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""You type “legislação municipal são paulo\"" - portuguese for \""municipal legislation sp\""  and the first option is  the city hall web site and the second option is the city council website, both of them present the municipal legislation. At the city hall website, you click in “Leis”, portuguese for “Law” in the main menu.  At the city council website you chick in \""Legislação\"", portuguese for \""Legislation\"" in the homepage's menu. "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.camara.sp.gov.br/transparencia/dados-abertos/ "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The search mechanism works well. So you can easily get all information about a specific law and analyse it.  ""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":"" São Paulo City council "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Câmara dos Vereadores de São Paulo""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Content of the law / status"",""Date of last amendment"",""Amendments to the law (if applicable)""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You can search the legislation by type of norm, number, year, author or keywords. As result we will have all this information related to the norm.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.camara.sp.gov.br/atividade-legislativa/splegis-consulta/"",""descValue"":""São Paulo City Council""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok",,"Yes","Yes","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"d87c6d2e-97e0-4a1e-b170-8531831fb2db","br-cities","2017-02-03T12:53:37","2017","sp","companies","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I can only get the data from company to company once I've selected the city i want the information from, or if i’ve got the name of the company or a unique identifier number like CNPJ.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""none""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Data is not downloadable. I can see a list of registered companies in São Paulo city, but i can only access the information on each company individually, and the data is only available online.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is free of charge, but i can only access it one by one. There is a private platform called SERASA, that sells a company’s list but this is a paid service. So it exists, it’s just not publicly available.""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Actually, there is no way of knowing if the data is up-to-date. There is a “date of issue”, which is not necessarily an indicator of the date of the last update, because it is automatically set as today’s date.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no clear license or terms of use for the data available from the website I provided. ""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not only it was not easy to find the platform but also, you need to have prior information on the company ID to get information. There is no official list beyond the one offered, so I have to look up on the internet for the company's name  individually.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""i googled registered companies in são paulo and got the JUCESP link."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":"" It is very hard to do anything with this information. I have to get the information one by one, no download is available.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""JUCESP - Junta Comercial do Estado de São Paulo"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Roughly translated as “São Paulo State board of trading” it’s a public entity that is subordinated technically to the National Department of Commerce Registration (DNRC), linked to the Ministry of Development, Industry and Foreign Trade. Jucesp is a state body that became part of the Secretariat of Economic Development, Science And Technology in January 2011.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Register available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""After I select any company from the online list i get the information checked. otherwise, not.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://www.jucesponline.sp.gov.br/ResultadoBusca.aspx "",""descValue"":""The search engine of JUCESP""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""if i select the city i can find all the companies registered in São Paulo.""}]","Yes","Yes","Reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","No","Bárbara Barbosa","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","35","35"
"33d324c7-b712-4627-9c68-3e5e25f2b7cc","br-cities","2017-02-02T16:26:24","2017","sp","elections","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""There are plenty of different datasets, depending on what kind of data is needed. They are usually downloaded via ZIP file containing a text file per unit established in the dataset choice. Inside it you have one .TXT file per federate state. In each of these files you have all municipalities from that state. You just have to look for São Paulo in this case.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""TXT""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data for 2016 Mayoral Elections was available one day after the counting process took place.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is public and regulated by the brazilian law of access to information (http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2011-2014/2011/lei/l12527.htm), but there is no specific open license for electoral data.""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data, since I’ve been working with them recently, so it was really easy to me. But if you search “Eleições resultados”, portuguese for “Election Results” in google, the first links are those from TSE.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I knew before that TSE was responsible for Election Results data, so I just went to TSE webpage (http://www.tse.jus.br/), 2) I searched the menu \""Elections\"" and then \""Elections Statistics\"", 3) I clicked the link for \""Election Data Repository\""."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/repositorio-de-dados-eleitorais"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link is the same of the homepage of the Electoral Data Repository from TSE. The text shows its public use intention, but there is no specific license for it. The information is regulated by the brazilian Law of Access to Information, as shown above, and because of that, it is considered public. This link (http://dados.gov.br/dataset/resultado-das-eleicoes/resource/bfd28046-7236-4a4a-82ef-3e0fcd92771c) shows that there is no specific license.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Some effort is required, since data is provided encoded. But all files come with a read-me file containing the correspondence between codes and descriptions.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""TSE - Tribunal Superior Eleitoral"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Mayoral elections data, just like national elections, is collected by the Brazilian Superior Electoral Court (TSE), the highest judiciary institution in Brazil for electoral issues.""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for mayoral elections"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I suppose that all the information required is the same as the Global Index requires, the only difference is that in this case it should be available for the municipality level, the mayoral elections: mayors and city councilmen.\n1) Mayoral Contests are available at the same platform as National Contests. For example: 2016 we had Municipal Contests and 2014, National Contests. Both happen every 4 years.\n2) One of the datasets available is \""Detalhe da apuração por município e zona\"" (Counting detail per municipality and electoral ward), which shows the total number of registered votes per municipality and electoral ward.\n3) The number of invalid votes can be obtained in the same dataset above. This dataset also includes abstentions.\n4) In Brazil, the voting process takes place with electronic ballot boxes. So, it doesn't make sense to have spoiled ballots data, but the number of invalid votes from subjury ballot boxes can be obtained through the same dataset above. Those are invalid votes until a electoral judge decides if they are actually valid or nullified. \n5) The \""Detalhe da apuração por seção eleitoral\"" (Counting detail per electoral section) dataset shows data per polling station (ballot box).""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/repositorio-de-dados-eleitorais"",""descValue"":""Main page for all brazilian election data (Repositório de dados eleitorais, which means Election Data Repository). The session \""results\"" in the left panel shows election results since 1945.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Here there is the general link for the TSE webpage. There are no specific links to get the information required for the dataset, but they are accessible through navigation. First, you choose the year and then you select what kind of dataset you need. In the case of São Paulo, a city, we are probably interested in mayoral elections, which take place every four years. We had one in 2016, so before that we had in 2012, 2008 and so forth.""}]","Yes","Yes","Dataset reviewed. Everything ok.",,"Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"5af3ad41-907f-4f27-b06d-234a9064fe63","br-cities","2017-02-02T17:11:48","2017","sp","transport","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Each information is provided separately, not only between transportation modes but also the type of information (itineraries separated from schedules separated from stations, etc).""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""DBF"",""SHP"",""SHX""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data is also provided in .PRJ, .DXF and .KMZ format, which are not on the list. Schedule information is not downloadable, but you can access it through an web application.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""By clicking in “metadata” at the GeoSampa portal, the downloaded .xls file contains information on update frequency. Even though bus lines and bus stops are updated daily (according to the sheet), bike lanes and bus corridors are updated every 6 months, bus terminals, train lines, train stations, subway lines and subway stations are updated yearly. Some information on railways is updated only “on demand”.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I had previous knowledge of the GeoSampa portal, so it was the first place I looked for the information. I found almost everything there, but I found the portal a little bit hard to get the information needed. I couldn’t visualize everything before downloading, so I was not a hundred percent sure that the information was right.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""1) I went straight to the GeoSampa portal. 2) I checked if every information needed was there. 3) I then downloaded every dataset to check again. 4) I complemented what I didn’t find there with information from other sources such as the São Paulo Open Data Portal and the specific websites from each transportation mode."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/cidade/secretarias/desenvolvimento_urbano/dados_estatisticos/"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The link for GeoSampa website advise that: The GeoSampa portal gathers detailed and georeferenced public information about the municipality, offering data availability in open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall. Data on bike lanes was also provided by an alternative link which is under a Creative Commons  CCZero License (as shown in the footer).  Schedule information had no specific license.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There are many formats in which data are available, but you should have some knowledge on geographic datasets in order to work with this (including knowledge in geographic softwares). I would also add the fact that data is scattered between many different sources, which makes it harder to work on data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Secretaria Municipal de Desenvolvimento Urbano"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The GeoSampa portal is hosted within the website of the Municipal Department of Urban Development of the Municipality of São Paulo. The Secretariat is the city's governing body responsible for urban planning.  ""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Stop/stations for every transportation mode"",""Itineraries for every line of every public transportation mode"",""Bike Lanes mapping for the entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""In the GeoSampa Portal, it is possible to add different layers in the transport domain through a menu of options to the right of the site where you can choose the layer with the information you want. When the download button is selected, you can choose the layer to download. The following layers were used: Corredores de ônibus (Bus Rapid Transit Itineraries); CPTM Estação (Train stations); CPTM Linha (Train itineraries); Ferrovia (Train itineraries); Metrô Estação (Subway stations); Metrô Linha (Subway itineraries); Terminais de ônibus (Bus stations); Rede Cicloviária (Bike Lanes Map); Ônibus Linha (Bus itineraries); Ônibus Ponto (Bus stops). Schedule information was found only for buses and trains.""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://geosampa.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/ "",""descValue"":""Main Portal""},{""urlValue"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/ciclovias"",""descValue"":""Bike Lanes Map Alternative Link""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.cptm.sp.gov.br/sua-viagem/Pages/sua-viagem.aspx"",""descValue"":""Train Schedule (CPTM - Companhia Paulista de Trens Metropolitanos)""},{""urlValue"":""http://itinerarios.extapps.sptrans.com.br/PlanOperWeb/"",""descValue"":""Bus Schedule""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.sptrans.com.br/desenvolvedores/APIOlhoVivo/Documentacao.aspx?1#docApi-previsao"",""descValue"":""SP Transport API with lines, corridor stops and real-time location.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""This is a geolocation tool that the city hall makes it available online and a also can download the data from it. GeoSampa gathers detailed and georeferenced information about the municipality, offering data available in an open format. The platform allows any citizen to access the maps and territorial information of the main information systems of the São Paulo City Hall. To select transport information, you have to add the desired layers, that doesn’t change the overall link. Information was found for Bus Rapid Transit itineraries (corridors), Train and Subway stations and itineraries, Bus terminals (stations), stops and lines and also bike lanes. For the last one, an alternative link is also provided. Schedule information was found separately for some transportation modes, as signaled in the other links.""}]","Yes","Yes","Just added the API for the transportation service as an alternative link.",,"Yes","No","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","65","65"
"4937e4bb-54f1-4f7f-be66-8a9c3596c130","br-cities","2017-04-18T17:59:50","2017","sp","education","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Download in bulk is available even though INEP data doesn't provide Coordinates to download.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""although its 2017 and the last data available is from 2015,based on previous knowledge i’m aware they launch the data referring to the last year (in this case, 2016) every march, so, i’ll tick yes here.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I'm acquainted with this kind of data, since I’ve been working with them for a long time, so it was really easy to me. But if you google “educação dados inep” you’ll get to the first page easily.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""To get enrollment data, public school data and type of school (kindergarten, elementary and high school) I can download the school census for each year and filter the options to get only São Paulo city data."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_Ato2015-2018/2016/Decreto/D8777.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I didn't find something as objective as a \""terms and conditions\"" or a real license, but the dataset is made available by an autarchy linked to the education ministry of the federal government, so it is considered licensed by the federal Decree 8.777/2016, Chapter II.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""There is no API but you can download the whole dataset at once in  processable format. it's clean and usable. the hardest part is to geolocate schools since the information is not provided and you would have to merge with other sources of data.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""INEP - Instituto Nacional de Estudos e Pesquisas Educacionais Anísio Teixeira"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The national research institute on education Anísio Teixeira is a federal autarchy linked to the Ministry of Education (MEC). Its objective is to promote studies, surveys and periodic evaluations on the Brazilian educational system""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Enrollment"",""Data available per public school"",""Data available for Kindergarten, Elementary and High School""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""on the school census i don't get lat/long or the school address. all other data are available. but i can get the school addresses in a collaborative map here: \thttp://www.educacao.sp.gov.br/central-de-atendimento/downloads.asp\nFor municipal schools, the information on coordinates can be found here: http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/cadastro-de-escolas-municipais-conveniadas-e-privadas""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://portal.inep.gov.br/web/guest/dados"",""descValue"":""Inep has a download page with all kinds of data""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.educacao.sp.gov.br/central-de-atendimento/downloads.asp"",""descValue"":""São Paulo Education Secretary also has a data webpage""},{""urlValue"":""https://sed.educacao.sp.gov.br/Geo/ConsultaPublica/TodasEscolas"",""descValue"":""São Paulo Education Secretary also has a collaboration map on school location, but the data is not downloadable.""},{""urlValue"":""http://dados.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/dataset/cadastro-de-escolas-municipais-conveniadas-e-privadas"",""descValue"":""The São Paulo open data portal disposes information on municipal schools only. Even though information is provided in open format, enrollment is not provided, only capacity.""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""I used the first link to evaluate school data situation, because it was the most comprehensive.""}]","Yes","Yes",,"This submission was revised in order to get a closer view on INEP data and complement it with other possible sources.","Yes","Yes","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","100","100"
"269ce46e-2931-42cb-a5e6-dc94fae27ff9","br-cities","2017-02-03T16:56:23","2017","sp","spending","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""You can get the whole dataset required through the API. There are many types of possible extractions, but the \""/ConsultarEmpenho\"" could provide all the information required.""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""JSON""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data can be retrieved through the API system in JSON format.\nSome other formats can be retrieved through the Transparency portal such as XLS, ODS and XML.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""Data was updated until one day before the consultation.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""You need to register and get a token to access all the data available through the API.""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""It was not easy to retrieve budget information through the API webpage. A person who worked inside the administration informed me about the existence of this API. I only knew the Transparency portal.""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Go to the São Paulo API webpage; Choose \""SOF\"" (finance and budget secretariat); follow the steps provided in the documentation."",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""https://api.prodam.sp.gov.br/store/apis/info?name=SOF&version=v2.1.0&provider=admin"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The terms of use are provided in the documentation, downloadable in pdf.""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Not only the process of getting the data is not very easy (at least you have a documentation to guide you through the steps required), but making data usable is hard once everything is codified. The full list of codes is not provided in the API portal, so you have to get it elsewhere.""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""São Paulo city hall "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""\n""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""All the data required can be retrieved through the /ConsultaEmpenhos category in the API console. There you can get all the information required only by choosing year and month as parameters. ""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""https://api.prodam.sp.gov.br/store/apis/info?name=SOF&version=v2.1.0&provider=admin"",""descValue"":""Budget API website""},{""urlValue"":""http://transparencia.prefeitura.sp.gov.br/contas/despesas/Paginas/default.aspx"",""descValue"":""Transparency Portal""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The assessment occurred based on the API website, because it was the place where all the information could be found in the most comprehensive availability. The second link is the transparency portal, which also provides information, but had some restrictions (individual record of transactions and name of vendor could not be found).""}]","Yes","Yes","This dataset was changed because the São Paulo API portal provided a more comprehensive dataset (the other one was incomplete).",,"Yes","No","Andressa Fioravanti","Wagner Faria de Oliveira","85","85"
"b26c4f73-1570-477c-9024-c81ad3f4f457","br-cities","2017-03-04T19:20:15","2017","cb","statistics","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Home page - 156 online - servicos - clique aqui"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Prefeitura de Curitiba"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Gross Domestic Product""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.central156.org.br/"",""descValue"":""""},{""urlValue"":""http://dadosabertos.c3sl.ufpr.br/curitiba/156/"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,"The user need to demand the city hall to access the data regarding 156 calls.","Yes","No","Camila Braga","Stephan Garcia","40","40"
"35a7c26b-522d-425f-bc1e-00a2218b236b","br-cities","2017-03-04T19:27:14","2017","cb","map","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""PDF""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""On Curitiba Web site we've found it by just searching for curitiba maps"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://ippuc.org.br/geodownloads/geo.htm"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""1"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""IPPUC - Instituto de Pesquisa e Planejamento Urbano de Curitiba"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Scale of 1:250,000 (1 cm = 2.5km)"",""Markings of traffic routes"",""Markings of relief/heights"",""Markings of water stretches"",""City borders""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.ippuc.org.br/default.php?pagina=348"",""descValue"":""Instituto filiado à Prefeitura de Curitiba ""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Fernando Carbonieri","Stephan Garcia","45","45"
"17637f42-5ba3-4914-98c1-8338ceac7b69","br-cities","2017-03-04T18:56:10","2017","cb","companies","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XLS""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""The file is compressed and when you open there is one file per year. For temporal analysis you need to unify files.""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""The data is updated annually. There is no monthly update.""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""I typed on google Foreign Trade Statistics"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.mdic.gov.br/servico-de-informacao-ao-cidadao-sic"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""2"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Ministry of Industry, Foreign Trade and Services"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Name of company"",""Company address"",""Unique identifier of the company"",""Register available for entire city""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.mdic.gov.br/balanca/outras/EMP_EXP.zip"",""descValue"":""Exporting companies 2001 to 2016 (by exported value range)""},{""urlValue"":""http://www.mdic.gov.br/balanca/outras/EMP_IMP.zip"",""descValue"":""Importing companies 2001 to 2016 (by imported value range)""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Alexsandro Brum","Stephan Garcia","85","85"
"86d6ace2-b67a-4e76-a807-4b4240e406bf","br-cities","2017-03-04T17:19:29","2017","cb","elections","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""HTML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""Site TRE eleições 2016"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Entrada no site do TRE bem descritivo Eleições, escolha o ano e forma como deseja extrair os dados""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/L9610.html"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""TRE Tribunal Regional Eleitoral "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Results for mayoral elections"",""Number of registered votes"",""Number of invalid votes"",""Number of spoiled ballots"",""Data available at polling station level""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""Na questão do nível de cédulas estragadas estou computando como nível de urnas estragadas""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://divulga.tse.jus.br/oficial/index.html"",""descValue"":""Site do TRE eleições 1º turno""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","leandro moraes","Stephan Garcia","100","100"
"64a31037-9e26-43dd-8b86-0645b33f5ec1","br-cities","2017-03-04T16:59:55","2017","cb","spending","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""But the csv was corrupted""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""CSV"",""HTML"",""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""http://www.curitiba.pr.gov.br/ , http://www.transparencia.curitiba.pr.gov.br/ , Despesa, Despesas - Planejamento e Execução Orçamentárias "",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":""http://www.transparencia.curitiba.pr.gov.br/sgp/despesas.aspx"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""Prefeitura de Curitiba"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Individual record of transactions"",""Government office which had the transaction"",""Date of transaction"",""Name of vendor"",""Amount of the transaction""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://www.transparencia.curitiba.pr.gov.br/sgp/despesasorcamentarias.aspx"",""descValue"":"" Despesas - Planejamento e Execução Orçamentária""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","Yes","Fernando Carbonieri","Stephan Garcia","100","100"
"dc8b2295-b1d4-487f-a3d6-41c71ab15c5c","br-cities","2017-03-04T16:29:14","2017","cb","budget","[{""id"":""bulk"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""format"",""value"":[""XML""],""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""timely"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_free"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""open_licence"",""value"":""No"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable"",""value"":""4"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""findable_steps"",""value"":""enter the url, select the city you want to get the data and the sector, download it"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""licence_url"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_gov"",""value"":""Yes"",""pass"":true,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""usability"",""value"":""3"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_name"",""value"":""TCE"",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""collector_non_gov"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""online_otherwise"",""value"":"""",""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""characteristics"",""value"":[""Budget per government department"",""Budget per sub-department"",""Descriptions for budget sections""],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""},{""id"":""location"",""value"":[{""urlValue"":""http://servicos.tce.pr.gov.br/TCEPR/Tribunal/Relacon/Dados/DadosConsulta/Consulta"",""descValue"":""""}],""pass"":false,""commentValue"":""""}]","Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Matheus Mariotto","Stephan Garcia","90","90"